Las Vegas Police Shooting Raises Questions About Use of Force During a Mental Health Crisis
Nearly three months after a Las Vegas police officer shot Catalina Alvarado in a College of Southern Nevada parking lot, the case is moving forward in criminal court. Alvarado pleaded not guilty on November 17 to charges stemming from the encounter. Her attorney, Carl Arnold, told 8 News Now that he plans to pursue a federal excessive-force lawsuit after the criminal case concludes. At the center of the dispute is how officers responded to a woman her attorney says was in a mental health crisis. 8 News Now reporting, republished by AOL · KTNV court coverage
What Happened on West Charleston Boulevard?
The shooting occurred shortly after 5:15 a.m. on August 28, 2026, at CSN’s Charleston campus near South Torrey Pines Drive. The Las Vegas Metropolitan Police Department says two officers were sitting in their patrol vehicles when Alvarado approached with a blade and struck the vehicles with it. According to Metro, Officer Delylah Donegan told Alvarado to drop the weapon. A second officer fired a Taser, but its probes hit Alvarado’s clothing and failed to stop her. Metro says Alvarado kept moving toward Donegan with the blade and Donegan fired once. Alvarado survived and, according to KTNV, spent three weeks in the hospital. LVMPD briefing · KTNV reporting
Metro says the officers tried to de-escalate the encounter. Arnold argues that Donegan’s words escalated it and that Alvarado’s repeated requests for officers to shoot her were signs of a crisis. Alvarado’s mother, Jacqueline Robles Marin Flores, told 8 News Now she believed the officer used unnecessary force against her daughter. Metro told KTNV that its investigation was ongoing and that Donegan remained on paid administrative leave pending review. 8 News Now reporting · KTNV reporting
How Courts Evaluate Police Use of Force
Under the Fourth Amendment, courts generally ask whether the force used during a police seizure was objectively reasonable from the perspective of a reasonable officer on the scene. In Barnes v. Felix, the U.S. Supreme Court explained that courts must consider the full circumstances, including relevant events leading up to the shooting. The Ninth Circuit, which includes Nevada, has also recognized that signs of a mental health crisis and the availability of less forceful options can matter in that analysis. U.S. Supreme Court opinion in Barnes v. Felix · Ninth Circuit opinion in Glenn v. Washington County
In an encounter like this one, some of the most important questions are concrete. How far apart were the officer and the person when the shot was fired? What could each officer see and hear? How much time passed between the Taser deployment and the shot? Was there time or space to create distance? Body-camera footage from both officers, nearby surveillance video if available, and the officers’ reports can help establish the sequence. Each camera captures a different angle, so comparing the recordings can help clarify what an officer could reasonably have perceived at the time. In cases where officers are dispatched to a scene, 911 recordings and dispatch logs can also show what they knew before arriving. That matters when the parties disagree over whether officers had reason to recognize a crisis before they used force. CEGA’s guide to evidence in Las Vegas police brutality claims
How the Criminal Case and a Civil Claim Differ
Alvarado faces charges that include assault on a protected person with a deadly weapon and resisting arrest with a deadly weapon. Prosecutors must prove the elements of each charge beyond a reasonable doubt. A federal civil rights lawsuit would ask whether the officer’s use of force violated Alvarado’s constitutional rights and what relief might be available. The same recording could matter in both proceedings. For example, it could show how Alvarado responded to police commands and help establish how close she was to Donegan when the officer fired. KTNV court coverage · Federal civil rights statute, 42 U.S.C. § 1983
Talk to a Las Vegas Police Misconduct Attorney
If you or a loved one was injured during a police encounter in Las Vegas, write down what happened while it’s fresh, keep any original photos or videos, and save medical records and witness contact information. An attorney can help identify additional evidence and take steps to preserve it. Call CEGA Criminal Law Group at (702) 253-6996 to discuss the incident and your options. Schedule a free consultation
Call Now:
info@cegalawgroup.com









